Resident Evil
Artist Judy A. Juracek has officially accused Capcom of stealing several of her photos for the creation of materials regarding some chapters of Resident Evil and Devil May Cry, with a lawsuit filed in Connecticut in recent days.According to what was reported by Juracek, several photos and graphic creations collected in the artist's book, entitled Surfaces, were taken without permission from Capcom and used for the creation of some elements of the games in question. The book is a collection of 1200 photographs of surfaces and textures all made by the same photographer, also distributed via CD-ROM and can only be used with a license for commercial use.
Resident Evil 4, the nuance of the logo under accusation According to reports from Juracek, "at least 80 photographs" have been used by Capcom without a license on over 200 different occasions. One of these would even be used for the creation of the Resident Evil 4 logo, visible as a nuance on the number "4", which would be taken from a particular photo of a shattered glass, taken in Italy.
Resident Evil 4, the detail on the door looks identical to that of Juracek's photo Another case concerns the detail of a wooden door, which the photographer took from a house in Newport, Rhode Island, reproduced precisely in Resident Evil 4 The coincidence is truly incredible, considering, however, that "Capcom could not have had access to the inside of the house to take this photograph", as reported in the documents.
There are also numerous other testimonies collected in the documents accompanying the prosecution, concerning assets inside the games and elements such as artwork or other, which led the photographer to request from 2,500 to 25,000 dollars as compensation for each photo used without permission. At this point, the official response from Capcom on the matter is awaited.
Have you noticed any errors?
Artist alleges Capcom stole her photos for the creation of multiple Resident Evil and Devil May Cry games
An artist has alleged Capcom stole her photos in the creation of Resident Evil and Devil May Cry games.
As reported by Polygon, designer Judy A. Juracek filed a lawsuit in a Connecticut court on Friday that alleges Capcom used unlicensed copyrighted photos for the creation of some of its games - and even for the Resident Evil 4 logo.
Eurogamer News Cast: will Sony's cross-gen U-turn hold PS5 games back?
At the heart of this lawsuit is Juracek's book, Surfaces, a visual research for artists, architects and designers that includes 1200 photographs of textures she took herself. Surfaces, which was originally published in 1996, includes a CD-ROM of the images, which require a licence for commercial use.
Juracek claims Capcom used at least 80 photographs without a licence in over 200 instances. She accuses Capcom of using a shattered glass texture from Surfaces in the creation of the Resident Evil 4 logo. Juracek said she took the photo of the glass in Italy.
Image credit Judy A. Juracek court documents / Polygon.Juracek also claims Capcom used a photo taken in a mansion in Newport, Rhode Island in the creation of Resident Evil 4. 'The public does not have access or permission to photograph the inside of the mansion,' the lawsuit claims. 'It is not possible for Capcom to have had access to the mansion to photograph such images.'
Image credit Judy A. Juracek court documents / Polygon.Juracek's lawsuit uses the 2020 Capcom data breach as evidence. As part of that data breach, high resolution images of artwork used in Resident Evil and other games was leaked, and file names for 'at least one of the images from the Capcom hacked files are the same file names as those used on the [Surfaces] CD-ROM', Juracek's lawyers claim. One metal texture labelled ME009 in the Surfaces CD-ROM is labelled the same in Capcom's folders, the lawsuit points out.
'... given that approximately 80 or more Juracek images appear in Resident Evil and that the primary brand/logo of Resident Evil employs a specific shattered glass pattern that matches a Juracek photo taken in Italy, as well as the interior mansion door design that the public does not have access to, it is hard to imagine that precise duplication would be possible by independent creation,' the lawyers argue.
'More specifically, it is hard to imagine that Juracek would take a photo of shattered glass in Italy and interior mansion door design and that Capcom artists would reproduce the exact same pattern of shattered glass in a logo and interior door design without benefit of Juracek's photographs.'
Juracek's lawyers seek up to $12m in damages for copyright infringement, as well as $2500 to $25,000 for each used photograph.
A Capcom representative told Polygon the company is 'aware of the lawsuit' and has 'no further comment.'
This isn't the first time Capcom has been accused of copying another's work. In May, Eurogamer reported on a movie director's claim Capcom copied his monster for a Resident Evil Village boss fight - something Juracek's lawyers point out in the suit.